Arguing about Muslims : (un)reasonable argumentation in letters to the editor | Macquarie University ResearchOnline

Home

List Of Titles

Arguing about Muslims : (un)reasonable argumentation in letters to the editor

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/1959.14/80145

42 Visitors

47 Hits

1 Downloads

Title: Arguing about Muslims : (un)reasonable argumentation in letters to the editor
Related: Text and talk, Vol. 27, No. 1, p.1-25
DOI: 10.1515/TEXT.2007.001
Publisher: Walter De Gruyter
Date: 2007
FoR/RFCD Code(s): 170200 Cognitive Sciences 200400 Linguistics
Author/Creator: Atkin, Albert
Author/Creator: Richardson, John E
Description: This article analyses letters to the editor written on or about Muslims printed in a British broadsheet newspaper. The pragma-dialectical theory of argumentation is applied as a model for explaining and understanding the arguments employed in the sampled letters. Our presentation of pragma-dialectical theory focuses on argumentative reasonableness. More specifically, we introduce the four dialectical stages through which any argument must pass and explain the ten rules of critical discussion that participants must follow throughout if they are to resolve the argument. The article focuses in particular on the letter writers' use of argument schemes-that is, the manner in which these writers use arguments to support their standpoints. We conclude by highlighting the role that unreasonable arguments can play in perpetuating racialized inequalities and hence the importance of analyzing argumentation.
Description: 25 page(s)
Subject Keyword: 170200 Cognitive Sciences
Subject Keyword: 200400 Linguistics
Subject Keyword: argumentation
Subject Keyword: reasonableness
Subject Keyword: broadsheet newspapers
Subject Keyword: pragma-dialectics
Subject Keyword: readers' letters
Subject Keyword: Muslims
Resource Type: journal article
Organisation: Macquarie University. Dept. of Philosophy

Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/1959.14/80145
Identifier: ISSN:1860-7349
Identifier: mq-rm-2007000938
Language: eng
Reviewed

Macquarie University ResearchOnline

Search

Browse

Highlights

Resources